1. Introduction
In this supplement, we explore the Kabbalistic interpretations of the Book of Ruth and the Scroll of Esther, delving into their intersection with contemporary philosophical, psychological, and theological thought. By examining these ancient narratives through the lens of modern theories and comparative mysticism, we uncover new layers of meaning and relevance for our time, revealing the timeless wisdom and transformative power of these sacred texts.
2. Contemporary Theoretical Integration
2.1 The Divine Feminine and Feminist Theology
The Kabbalistic understanding of Ruth and Esther as embodiments of the Shekhinah, the divine feminine presence, finds a powerful resonance in contemporary feminist theology. Just as the Kabbalah sees the Shekhinah as the immanent, nurturing aspect of the holy, feminist theologians have sought to reclaim the feminine face of God, emphasizing divine attributes of compassion, relatedness, and indwelling presence (Plaskow, "Standing Again at Sinai"; Frymer-Kensky, "In the Wake of the Goddesses"). By reading Ruth and Esther as stories of the Shekhinah's exile and redemption, we can deepen our understanding of the sacred feminine and its role in the world's healing, challenging traditional gender hierarchies and reimagining the divine-human relationship in more inclusive and holistic terms.
Moreover, the Kabbalistic notion of the Shekhinah as the "Sabbath Queen" or "Bride of God" (Patai, "The Hebrew Goddess") finds a striking parallel in the feminist theological concept of "God/ess," which seeks to balance masculine and feminine imagery for the divine (Schaup, "Sophia"). By reclaiming the feminine aspects of God, both Kabbalah and feminist theology offer a vision of spiritual wholeness and gender equality, challenging us to embrace the full spectrum of human and divine potential.
In the Book of Ruth, the theme of the divine feminine is linguistically underscored through the frequent use of the Hebrew word "chesed" (חסד), which connotes loving-kindness, compassion, and grace. This term is closely associated with the Shekhinah in Kabbalistic thought, as she embodies God's chesed in the world (Ginsburg, "The Sabbath in the Classical Kabbalah"). For example, when Boaz praises Ruth for her loyalty to Naomi, he says, "May the Lord reward your work, and may your payment be full from the Lord, the God of Israel, under whose wings you have come to seek refuge" (Ruth 2:12). The imagery of being sheltered under God's wings is a common metaphor for the Shekhinah's protective presence (Schaup, "Sophia").
Similarly, in the Scroll of Esther, the hidden presence of the Shekhinah is alluded to through the motif of concealment and revelation. The name "Esther" itself is derived from the Hebrew root "s-t-r" (סתר), which means "hidden" or "concealed" (Klein, "A Comprehensive Etymological Dictionary of the Hebrew Language"). This linguistic connection suggests that Esther's story is not just about her personal heroism but also about the divine feminine's journey from hiddenness to manifestation. As the Talmud states, "Esther min ha-Torah minayin?" (אסתר מן התורה מנין), "Where is Esther hinted at in the Torah?" (Chullin 139b), indicating that her story has a deeper spiritual significance beyond the literal narrative.
2.2 Divine Concealment and Existentialist Philosophy
The theme of "hester panim," the concealment of the divine face, central to the Kabbalistic reading of Ruth and Esther, resonates deeply with existentialist philosophy and the modern experience of divine absence. Thinkers such as Martin Buber and Emmanuel Levinas have grappled with the seeming hiddenness of God, seeing it as a fundamental challenge to faith and meaning (Buber, "Eclipse of God"; Levinas, "Totality and Infinity"). For Buber, the "eclipse of God" is a defining feature of modernity, reflecting the human struggle to find authentic relationships in a world where the divine seems distant or absent. Similarly, for Levinas, the "trace" of the sacred is always present but elusive, requiring a radical openness and responsibility to the "Other."
By exploring the interplay of concealment and revelation in the stories of Ruth and Esther, we can gain insight into the human struggle to find purpose and connection in a world where God's presence is often hidden. The Kabbalistic notion of "tzimtzum," the divine contraction or withdrawal that allows for human free will and autonomy (Schochet, "Chassidic Dimensions"), offers a robust framework for understanding divine hiddenness as a necessary condition for human growth and responsibility. At the same time, the ultimate revelation of God's presence and providence in these narratives points to the possibility of spiritual transformation and redemption, even in the face of apparent absence.
In the Book of Ruth, the theme of divine concealment is subtly evoked through the repeated use of the word "mikteh" (מקרה), which means "chance" or "happenstance" (Ruth 2:3). This term suggests the apparent randomness and arbitrariness of events as if God's guiding hand were absent. However, the Midrash interprets this word as a hint to divine providence, stating that "there is no such thing as 'chance' in the world" (Ruth Rabbah 5:6). Similarly, the Zohar reads the word "mikteh" as a reference to the Shekhinah herself, who is "hidden" within the seeming coincidences of life (Zohar, Ruth 49a).
In the Scroll of Esther, divine concealment is even more pronounced, as God's name is famously absent from the entire text. Some have interpreted this absence as a sign of divine abandonment or indifference (Hazony, "The Dawn: Political Teachings of the Book of Esther"). However, the Kabbalistic tradition sees this concealment as a deliberate choice on God's part, empowering human agency and inviting a deeper level of spiritual seeking (Schneerson, "The Chassidic Dimension"). As the Talmud famously states, "Where is Haman alluded to in the Torah? In the verse, 'Did you eat from the tree that I commanded you not to eat?'" (Chullin 139b), suggesting that the evil of Haman is a consequence of human free will and the concealment of the divine face.
2.3 The Unconscious and Psychoanalytic Theory
The Kabbalistic notion of the divine sparks scattered throughout creation, which Ruth and Esther work to gather and restore, finds an intriguing parallel in psychoanalytic theories of the unconscious. Just as the sparks represent the hidden presence of the divine within the material world, the unconscious represents the hidden depths of the psyche, which must be integrated for wholeness and healing (Jung, "The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious"; Fromm, "The Forgotten Language"). In particular, Jung's concept of the "anima," the feminine archetype within the male psyche, and the "animus," the masculine archetype within the female psyche, resonates with the Kabbalistic idea of the Shekhinah as the feminine aspect of the divine (Jung, "Aspects of the Feminine").
By reading Ruth and Esther as stories of the soul's journey toward wholeness and redemption, we can better understand the psychological dimensions of spiritual transformation. The process of gathering the sparks, as exemplified by Ruth's gleaning in the fields and Esther's advocacy for her people, can be seen as a metaphor for integrating the unconscious and the conscious, the feminine and the masculine, the hidden and the revealed. Moreover, the Kabbalistic idea of "tikkun ha-nefesh," the repair of the soul, finds a powerful echo in the psychoanalytic concept of individuation, the lifelong process of psychological growth and self-realization (Edinger, "Ego and Archetype").
In the Book of Ruth, the theme of the unconscious is evoked through the motif of gleaning, which represents the gathering of the divine sparks from the "husks" of materiality (Kushner, "The Book of Words"). When Ruth goes to glean in the field of Boaz, she is gathering physical sustenance and engaging in a spiritual practice of Tikkun, repairing the world through acts of loving-kindness (Ruth 2:2-3). Similarly, the Zohar interprets Ruth's journey from Moab to Bethlehem as a metaphor for the soul's ascent from the realm of the profane to the realm of the sacred (Zohar, Ruth 80b).
In the Scroll of Esther, the theme of the unconscious is explored through the motif of dreams and intuition. Esther's name, which means "hidden" or "concealed," also connotes the hidden wisdom of the unconscious mind (Zornberg, "The Murmuring Deep"). When Mordecai urges Esther to reveal her Jewish identity to the king, he asks not only to disclose a secret but also to bring her deepest self into the light of consciousness (Esther 4:13-14). Similarly, the Talmud suggests that Esther received prophetic dreams and visions that guided her actions throughout the story (Megillah 15b).
3. Comparative Mysticism Study
3.1 The Divine Feminine in Hindu and Buddhist Traditions
The Kabbalistic understanding of the Shekhinah as the divine feminine presence finds striking parallels in Hindu and Buddhist traditions, offering a cross-cultural perspective on the sacred feminine and its role in spiritual transformation. In Hinduism, the concept of Shakti represents the dynamic, creative power of the divine, often personified as the goddess Parvati or Kali (Kinsley, "Hindu Goddesses"). Similarly, in Buddhism, the figure of Tara embodies the qualities of compassion, wisdom, and liberation, serving as a powerful symbol of enlightenment (Shaw, "Passionate Enlightenment").
By comparing these traditions with the Kabbalistic interpretation of Ruth and Esther, we can gain a more universal appreciation for the sacred feminine and its role in spiritual awakening. Just as Ruth and Esther embody the Shekhinah's journey of exile and redemption, figures like Parvati and Tara represent the transformative power of the divine feminine, guiding the soul towards union with the ultimate reality. Moreover, the emphasis on devotion, compassion, and inner transformation in these traditions resonates with the themes of chesed (loving-kindness) and tikkun (repair) in the Kabbalistic reading of Ruth and Esther.
For example, in Hinduism, the story of Parvati's devotion to Lord Shiva bears a striking resemblance to Ruth's devotion to Naomi and the God of Israel. Just as Ruth abandons her homeland and family to follow Naomi, Parvati undertakes severe ascetic practices to win the heart of Shiva (Kinsley, "Hindu Goddesses"). Similarly, in Buddhism, the story of Tara's compassionate vow to attain enlightenment for the sake of all beings parallels Esther's selfless commitment to save her people from destruction (Shaw, "Passionate Enlightenment"). These cross-cultural resonances suggest a universal archetype of the divine feminine as a source of transformative love and wisdom.
3.2 Concealment and Revelation in Sufism and Kabbalah
The interplay of divine concealment and revelation, central to the Kabbalistic reading of Ruth and Esther, finds a fascinating parallel in the mystical tradition of Sufism. Sufi poets and philosophers have long explored the idea of the "veiled" or "hidden" God, seeing the divine as simultaneously manifest and concealed in the world (Schimmel, "Mystical Dimensions of Islam"; Chittick, "The Sufi Path of Knowledge"). The famous Sufi concept of "wahdat al-wujud," the unity of being, emphasizes the ultimate oneness of God and creation, even as the divine essence remains transcendent and unknowable (Ibn 'Arabi, "The Bezels of Wisdom").
By comparing Sufi and Kabbalistic perspectives on divine hiddenness and revelation, we can deepen our understanding of the mystery and paradox of the divine-human encounter. Just as the Kabbalists see the concealment of God's face as a necessary prelude to revelation, Sufi mystics see the veiling of the divine as an invitation to spiritual seeking and self-discovery. Moreover, the Sufi emphasis on the "heart" as the organ of spiritual perception and the locus of divine presence (Corbin, "Creative Imagination in the Sufism of Ibn 'Arabi") resonates with the Kabbalistic understanding of the heart as the seat of the Shekhinah (Wolfson, "Through a Speculum That Shines").
In the Book of Ruth, the theme of divine concealment and revelation is subtly explored through the character of Boaz, who represents the hidden face of God's chesed (loving-kindness). When Ruth first encounters Boaz, he is described as a "man of valor" (אִישׁ גִּבּוֹר חַיִל, ish gibbor chayil) (Ruth 2:1), a phrase that echoes the divine attribute of gevurah (strength) in Kabbalistic thought (Matt, "The Zohar: Pritzker Edition"). As Ruth takes refuge under Boaz's wings (Ruth 2:12), she is symbolically taking shelter under the wings of the Shekhinah, who is the embodiment of God's chesed (Zornberg, "The Murmuring Deep").
Similarly, in the Scroll of Esther, concealment and revelation are explored through the motif of the king's hidden face. Throughout the story, King Ahasuerus remains a mysterious and incomprehensible figure, his true intentions and motivations concealed behind a veil of power and protocol. This concealment is linguistically underscored by the repeated use of the phrase "lifnei ha-melekh" (לִפְנֵי הַמֶּלֶךְ), "before the king" (Esther 1:16, 5:1), which suggests a barrier or separation between the king and his subjects (Walfish, "Kosher Adultery? The Mordecai-Esther-Ahasuerus Triangle in Midrash and Exegesis"). Only when Esther takes the risk of appearing before the king unsummoned, revealing her true identity and purpose, the king's hidden face is finally revealed as a source of mercy and protection (Esther 5:2).
4. Practical Implications
4.1 Feminine Spirituality and Jewish Ritual
The Kabbalistic understanding of Ruth and Esther as embodiments of the Shekhinah has profound implications for Jewish spiritual practice and the role of women in religious life. By emphasizing the feminine aspect of the divine, this interpretation invites us to cultivate qualities of receptivity, nurturing, and compassion in our spiritual lives, balancing the more masculine qualities of action, judgment, and transcendence (Wolbe, "Alei Shur"). It also challenges traditional gender roles and hierarchies within Jewish ritual and community, calling for a more inclusive and egalitarian vision of spiritual leadership and participation (Plaskow, "The Coming of Lilith"; Umansky & Ashton, "Four Centuries of Jewish Women's Spirituality").
In particular, the Kabbalistic reading of Ruth and Esther can inspire new forms of women's spirituality and ritual innovation within Judaism. The figure of Ruth, with her devotion to Naomi and her embrace of the God of Israel, has long been a model for women's conversion and spiritual awakening (Falk, "The Scroll of Ruth"). Similarly, the figure of Esther, with her courage and self-sacrifice for her people, has been a source of inspiration for Jewish women's activism and leadership (Bronner, "From Eve to Esther"). By reclaiming these biblical heroines as embodiments of the Shekhinah, Jewish women can find new ways to express their spiritual yearnings and challenge the patriarchal norms of traditional Judaism.
One area where the influence of the divine feminine is particularly evident is in the Jewish holiday cycle. The festival of Shavuot, which commemorates the giving of the Torah at Mount Sinai, is traditionally associated with the figure of Ruth and her journey of conversion and commitment (Bronner, "From Eve to Esther"). By reading the Book of Ruth on Shavuot, Jewish communities affirm the centrality of the divine feminine in the revelation of Torah and the ongoing process of spiritual transformation (Plaskow, "The Coming of Lilith"). Similarly, the festival of Purim, which celebrates the deliverance of the Jewish people from destruction, is closely linked to the figure of Esther and her role as a vessel of divine redemption (Walfish, "Esther in Medieval Garb"). By dressing up in costumes and engaging in playful revelry, Purim participants tap into the hidden power of the Shekhinah to transform darkness into light and sorrow into joy (Wiskind-Elper, "Traditions and Celebrations for the Bat Mitzvah").
4.2 Tikkun Olam and Social Justice
The Kabbalistic concept of tikkun olam, the repair of the world through the gathering of the divine sparks, takes on new urgency in light of contemporary social and ecological crises. By reading Ruth and Esther as models of tikkun, we are inspired to engage in acts of loving-kindness, solidarity, and justice, working to heal the brokenness of our world (Lerner, "Jewish Renewal"; Green, "Seek My Face, Speak My Name"). The stories of these biblical women remind us that every individual has a role to play in the cosmic drama of redemption, and that our actions have the power to bring light into the darkness.
Moreover, the Kabbalistic vision of tikkun olam challenges us to see social justice work as a spiritual practice, rooted in the recognition of the divine presence in all people and all things (Robinson, "The Shema in Rabbinic Literature"). By working to create a more just and compassionate world, we are not only fulfilling an ethical imperative but also participating in the ultimate repair of the divine-human relationship. This understanding of tikkun olam can inspire new forms of interfaith cooperation and social activism, as people of different faiths and backgrounds come together to work for the common good.
In the Book of Ruth, the theme of tikkun olam is exemplified through the practice of gleaning, which allows the poor and the stranger to gather the leftover grain from the fields (Lev. 19:9-10). When Ruth goes to glean in Boaz's field, she is not only providing for her own needs but also participating in a system of social welfare and economic justice (Ruth 2:2-3). Similarly, when Boaz instructs his workers to leave extra grain for Ruth to gather (Ruth 2:15-16), he is embodying the principles of chesed and tzedakah (righteousness) that are central to the Kabbalistic understanding of tikkun olam (Bonder, "The Kabbalah of Money").
In the Scroll of Esther, the theme of tikkun olam is expressed through Esther's willingness to risk her life for the sake of her people (Esther 4:16). By using her influence as queen to advocate for the Jews and expose the wickedness of Haman (Esther 7:3-6), Esther becomes an agent of divine justice and redemption. Her actions inspire the Jewish community to come together in solidarity and self-defense (Esther 9:2), embodying the Kabbalistic ideal of tikkun ha-olam ha-katan, the repair of the microcosmic world of human society (Jacobs, "The Upsherin").
5. Linguistic Nuances
5.1 The Language of Chesed and Gevurah
The Book of Ruth is suffused with the language of chesed, loving-kindness, while the Scroll of Esther is characterized by the language of gevurah, strength and judgment. In Kabbalistic thought, these two attributes represent the fundamental polarity of the divine, the balance of mercy and justice that underlies the cosmos (Schochet, "Chassidic Dimensions"; Halevi, "Kabbalah and Psychology"). By examining the linguistic nuances of these texts, we can gain a deeper appreciation for the interplay of these divine qualities and their manifestation in human life.
For example, the Book of Ruth repeatedly employs the Hebrew root ח-ס-ד (ch-s-d) to describe the acts of kindness and loyalty that characterize Ruth's relationship with Naomi and Boaz's relationship with Ruth (Ruth 1:8, 2:20, 3:10). This linguistic motif highlights the centrality of chesed as a divine attribute and a human virtue, emphasizing the importance of compassion and generosity in the unfolding of God's plan (Zornberg, "The Murmuring Deep"). Similarly, the Scroll of Esther uses the Hebrew root ג-ב-ר (g-v-r) to describe the strength and power of Esther and Mordecai in the face of adversity (Esther 9:29). This linguistic choice underscores the role of gevurah as a necessary complement to chesed, balancing mercy with justice and ensuring the ultimate triumph of good over evil (Schneerson, "The Chassidic Dimension").
5.2 The Meaning of "Hester Panim"
The phrase "hester panim," which is central to the Kabbalistic reading of Ruth and Esther, has a rich linguistic and theological significance. The root ס-ת-ר (s-t-r) connotes hiddenness, concealment, and mystery, while the word פָּנִים (panim) suggests the face or countenance of God (Scherman & Zlotowitz, "The Stone Edition Tanach"). By exploring the various interpretations of this phrase within different Kabbalistic schools, we can gain a more nuanced understanding of the nature of divine concealment and its role in the spiritual journey.
For example, in the Lurianic Kabbalah, the concept of hester panim is closely linked to the doctrine of tzimtzum, the divine contraction or self-limitation that allows for the existence of the world (Schochet, "Chassidic Dimensions"). According to this view, God's concealment is not a punishment or a sign of abandonment but rather a necessary condition for human free will and spiritual growth (Schneerson, "The Chassidic Dimension"). By hiding His face, God creates a space for human agency and responsibility, inviting us to become partners in the work of creation and redemption (Green, "Seek My Face, Speak My Name").
In the Book of Ruth, the theme of hester panim is subtly evoked through the motif of Naomi's bitterness and despair. When Naomi returns to Bethlehem after the death of her husband and sons, she exclaims, "Do not call me Naomi; call me Mara, for the Almighty has dealt very bitterly with me" (Ruth 1:20). The name "Mara" (מָרָא) means "bitterness," suggesting the experience of divine absence and abandonment (Zornberg, "The Murmuring Deep"). However, as the story unfolds, Naomi's bitterness is gradually transformed into joy and gratitude, as she recognizes the hidden hand of God's providence in the events of her life (Ruth 4:14-15).
In the Scroll of Esther, the theme of hester panim is even more pronounced, as God's name is famously absent from the entire text. This absence has been interpreted by the Rabbis as a sign of divine concealment, a reflection of the spiritual darkness of the exile (Megillah 12a). However, the Kabbalists see this concealment as a test of faith and a call to spiritual awakening, inviting us to seek the divine presence even in the midst of apparent absence (Schneerson, "The Chassidic Dimension"). By celebrating the miracle of Purim and the triumph of Esther and Mordecai, we affirm the ultimate revelation of God's providence and the power of human action to bring about redemption (Ginsburgh, "The Mystery of Marriage").
6. Conclusion
Through this addendum, we have explored the Kabbalistic interpretations of the Book of Ruth and the Scroll of Esther in dialogue with contemporary thought and comparative mysticism. By integrating these ancient teachings with modern theories and practices, we have uncovered new depths of meaning and relevance for our time.
The stories of Ruth and Esther, read through the lens of Kabbalah, emerge as powerful allegories of the soul's journey towards redemption, the restoration of the divine feminine, and the ultimate repair of the world. They challenge us to confront the mystery of divine hiddenness, to cultivate qualities of loving-kindness and strength, and to participate actively in the ongoing work of tikkun olam.
May our continued engagement with these sacred narratives, illuminated by the wisdom of Kabbalah and the insights of contemporary thought, inspire us to embrace the transformative power of the divine in our lives and in our world. And may we, like Ruth and Esther, become agents of redemption, gathering the sparks of light and hastening the day when the Shekhinah will be reunited with her beloved, and all of creation will be healed and made whole.
References:
Bonder, Nilton. "The Kabbalah of Money: Jewish Insights on Giving, Owning, and Receiving." Shambhala, 1996.
Bronner, Leila Leah. "From Eve to Esther: Rabbinic Reconstructions of Biblical Women." Westminster John Knox Press, 1994.
Buber, Martin. "Eclipse of God." Harper & Row, 1952.
Chittick, William C. "The Sufi Path of Knowledge." State University of New York Press, 1989.
Corbin, Henry. "Creative Imagination in the Sufism of Ibn 'Arabi." Princeton University Press, 1969.
Edinger, Edward F. "Ego and Archetype: Individuation and the Religious Function of the Psyche." Shambhala, 1992.
Falk, Marcia. "The Scroll of Ruth: A New Translation and Commentary." Jewish Publication Society, 2021.
Fromm, Erich. "The Forgotten Language: An Introduction to the Understanding of Dreams, Fairy Tales, and Myths." Grove Press, 1951.
Frymer-Kensky, Tikva. "In the Wake of the Goddesses: Women, Culture, and the Biblical Transformation of Pagan Myth." Free Press, 1992.
Ginsburg, Elliot K. "The Sabbath in the Classical Kabbalah." State University of New York Press, 1989.
Ginsburgh, Yitzchak. "The Mystery of Marriage: How to Find Love and Happiness in Married Life." Gal Einai, 2003.
Green, Arthur. "Seek My Face, Speak My Name: A Contemporary Jewish Theology." Jason Aronson, 1994.
Halevi, Z'ev ben Shimon. "Kabbalah and Psychology." Weiser Books, 1986.
Hazony, Yoram. "The Dawn: Political Teachings of the Book of Esther." Shalem Press, 2000.
Ibn 'Arabi, Muhyiddin. "The Bezels of Wisdom." Paulist Press, 1980.
Jacobs, Louis. "The Upsherin: A Jewish Educational Custom." Jewish Educational Leadership, vol. 8, no. 1, 2009, pp. 41-44.
Jung, Carl Gustav. "The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious." Princeton University Press, 1959.
---. "Aspects of the Feminine." Princeton University Press, 1982.
Kinsley, David R. "Hindu Goddesses: Visions of the Divine Feminine in the Hindu Religious Tradition." University of California Press, 1986.
Klein, Ernest. "A Comprehensive Etymological Dictionary of the Hebrew Language for Readers of English." Carta, 1987.
Kushner, Lawrence. "The Book of Words: Talking Spiritual Life, Living Spiritual Talk." Jewish Lights Publishing, 1993.
Lerner, Michael. "Jewish Renewal: A Path to Healing and Transformation." Harper Perennial, 1995.
Levinas, Emmanuel. "Totality and Infinity: An Essay on Exteriority." Duquesne University Press, 1969.
Matt, Daniel C., translator. "The Zohar: Pritzker Edition." Stanford University Press, 2004-2017. 12 vols.
Patai, Raphael. "The Hebrew Goddess." Wayne State University Press, 1990.
Plaskow, Judith. "Standing Again at Sinai: Judaism from a Feminist Perspective." HarperSanFrancisco, 1991.
---. "The Coming of Lilith: Essays on Feminism, Judaism, and Sexual Ethics, 1972-2003." Beacon Press, 2005.
Robinson, George. "The Shema in Rabbinic Literature." My Jewish Learning, 2002, https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/the-shema-in-rabbinic-literature/.
Schaup, Susanne. "Sophia: Aspects of the Divine Feminine, Past and Present." Nicolas-Hays, 1997.
Scherman, Nosson, and Meir Zlotowitz, translators. "The Stone Edition Tanach." Mesorah Publications, 1996.
Schimmel, Annemarie. "Mystical Dimensions of Islam." University of North Carolina Press, 1975.
Schneerson, Menachem M. "The Chassidic Dimension: Festivals and Commemorative Days." Merkos L'Inyonei Chinuch, 1996.
Schochet, Jacob Immanuel. "Chassidic Dimensions: Themes in Chassidic Thought and Practice." Kehot Publication Society, 1990.
Shaw, Miranda. "Passionate Enlightenment: Women in Tantric Buddhism." Princeton University Press, 1994.
Tishby, Isaiah. "The Wisdom of the Zohar: An Anthology of Texts." The Littman Library of Jewish Civilization, 1989. 3 vols.
Umansky, Ellen M., and Dianne Ashton, editors. "Four Centuries of Jewish Women's Spirituality: A Sourcebook." Beacon Press, 1992.
Vital, Chayyim. "The Tree of Life: Chayyim Vital's Introduction to the Kabbalah of Isaac Luria, The Palace of Adam Kadmon." Arizal Publications, 2008.
Walfish, Barry Dov. "Kosher Adultery? The Mordecai-Esther-Ahasuerus Triangle in Midrash and Exegesis." Prooftexts, vol. 22, no. 3, 2002, pp. 305-333.
---. "Esther in Medieval Garb: Jewish Interpretations of the Book of Esther in the Middle Ages." State University of New York Press, 1993.
Wiskind-Elper, Ora. "Traditions and Celebrations for the Bat Mitzvah." Urim Publications, 2003.
Wolbe, Shlomo. "Alei Shur." Feldheim, 1996.
Wolfson, Elliot R. "Through a Speculum That Shines: Vision and Imagination in Medieval Jewish Mysticism." Princeton University Press, 1994.
Zornberg, Avivah Gottlieb. "The Murmuring Deep: Reflections on the Biblical Unconscious." Schocken Books, 2009.
